Originally submitted 2008. Directions from the intersection of US-22 and Washington St, New Alexandria, PA: Head south on Washington St for 0.2 mi; cemetery will be in front of you - 212 Church St
| No | Lastname | First,Middle,Maiden Names | Birth | Death | Plot | Inscriptions | Notes |
| 1 | Cox  | Lucetta M | 03/30/1843 | 07/09/1902 | | | w/o James, aged 59Y 3M 10D |
| 2 | Dermond | Jane J | __/__/__ | 12/03/1850 | | | aged 40Y |
| 3 | Johnston | Family Monument | __/__/__ | __/__/__ | | | |
| 4 | Johnston | James H | __/__/__ | 08/26/1857 | | | Father, aged 77Y |
| 5 | Johnston | James | __/__/__ | 06/03/1850 | | | aged 38Y |
| 6 | Johnston | John | __/__/__ | __/__/__ | | | aged 4Y |
| 7 | Johnston | Mary Hemphill | __/__/__ | 07/22/1867 | | | w/o James H, Mother, aged 83Y |
| 8 | Johnston | Mary A | __/__/__ | 03/25/1847 | | | aged 31Y |
| 9 | Johnston | Miranda | __/__/__ | 01/05/1843 | | | aged 16Y |
| 10 | Johnston | Nancy | __/__/__ | __/__/__ | | | aged 2Y |
| 11 | Johnston | Robert | __/__/__ | 02/11/1867 | | | aged 58Y |
| 12 | Johnston | Samuel | __/__/__ | 04/15/1847 | | | aged 25Y |
| 13 | Johnston | Sarah | __/__/__ | 03/03/1851 | | | aged 25Y |
| 14 | Johnston | William G | __/__/__ | 12/01/1856 | | | aged 37Y |
| 15 | McCurdy | Archibald | __/__/1832 | __/__/1878 | | | Father |
| 16 | McCurdy | Malinda | __/__/1841 | __/__/1885 | | | w/o Archibald, Mother |
| 17 | Moorhead | James | __/__/__ | 10/18/1858 | | | aged 66Y 4M 6D |
| 18 | Moorhead | Lillias | __/__/__ | 06/05/1862 | | | aged 60Y 5M 13D |
| 19 | Mourer | Elizabeth C | __/__/__ | 11/11/1841 | | | d/o John & Susan, aged 8Y 6M 10D |
| 20 | Mourer | Margaret | __/__/__ | 11/28/1841 | | | d/o John & Susan, aged 4Y 10M 12D |
| 21 | Mourer | Susan | __/__/__ | 12/04/1844 | | | w/o John, aged 33Y |
| 22 | Mourrer | Capt John | __/__/__ | 09/14/1870 | | | aged 63Y, GAR Marker |
| 23 | Patterson | Katharine | __/__/__ | 06/17/1836 | | | relict of Samuel aged 60Y |
| 24 | Quinn | James | __/__/__ | 06/01/1868 | | | in the 72 Year |
| 25 | Quinn | Mary L | __/__/__ | 11/02/1861 | | | w/o James, in the 78 year |
| 26 | Shaw | Isabella | __/__/1827 | __/__/1898 | | | |
| 27 | Shaw | James | __/__/1799 | __/__/1881 | | | |
| 28 | Shaw | Jennie | __/__/1788 | __/__/1850 | | | w/o Wm |
| 29 | Shaw | Mary A | __/__/1889 | __/__/1932 | | | |
| 30 | Shaw | Nancy E | __/__/1834 | __/__/1904 | | | w/o W D |
| 31 | Shaw | Sarah J | __/__/1842 | __/__/1878 | | | w/o W D |
| 32 | Shaw | Susanna | __/__/1798 | __/__/1870 | | | w/o James |
| 33 | Shaw | W D | __/__/1832 | __/__/1909 | | | |
| 34 | Shaw | William | __/__/1780 | __/__/1837 | | | |
| 35 | Sheffler | Elizabeth | __/__/__ | 12/22/1874 | | | w/o John, aged 74Y 8M 9D |
| 36 | Sheffler | John | __/__/__ | 08/21/1853 | | | aged 51Y 7M 2D |
| 37 | Torrance | Rev Adam | __/__/__ | 10/18/1881 | | | aged 80Y 5M 24,D Our First Pastor 12 Jun 1836?- 04 Apr 1867, GAR Marker |
| 38 | Torrance | Eliza | __/__/__ | 04/23/8188 | | | w/o Rev A, in the 74 Year |
| 39 | Winings | Mary | __/__/__ | 04/22/1872 | | | w/o William, in the 69 Year |
| 40 | Winings | Matilda | __/__/__ | __/__/1866 | | | w/o B M, aged 33Y 6M 20D |
| 41 | Winings | W Torrence | __/__/__ | 09/07/1859 | | | s/o W & M, aged 18Y 11M 19D |
| 42 | Winings | William | __/__/__ | 5/__/1882 | | | in his 80 Year |
